Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood - Episode 48 Review
Episode 48, " A Vow Made Underground"

*****SPOILERS*****
Synopsis: Ling and Ranfan team up to take on Gluttony, easily taking out several of his lives due to their ability to sense him, which Fu (who suddenly appears) explains to Edward. The lights in the slums begin to come back on, concerning Ed and Darius, and Ed comes up with a plan involving Fu. Heinkel continues to attack Selim, but doesn't make very much progress. Meanwhile, Roy meets with Madam Christmas and recieves confirmation that Selim isn't human. Villagers happen upon Heinkel and Selim and Selim scares them, causing one to drop a lantern. The fire allows Pride to use his abilities, but Edward saves him. In Central, soldiers try to get at Roy at Madam Christmas's bar, but he blows it up and the two escape in the sewers. Roy meets with Hawkeye, Breda, and Fuery in a hideout underground as they prepare to go into action, and he tells them not to die. Pride, unable to hurt Ed because of his use of carbon hardening on his automail, decides to use Alphonse to fight Ed, but Ed has Fu use a flashback which seperates Al long enough to be carried off. Gluttony races to meet with Pride, who he informs of the many lives he's lost. Pride takes this chance to devour Gluttony to gain his sense of smell in order to find his opponents in the dark. In Central, Father wonders what Roy plans to do next, and Olivier says that he will probably kidnap the Fuhrer's wife. Roy does just that.


Comments:
Perhaps it's because this episode covers a single chapter rather than two and I'm used to the faster pace, but this episode seemed so bloated and dragged out. I understand lengthening the action for excitement purposes, and it worked, it was pretty awesome, but some of those other bits were just death. This episode was just not that great in the big picture.
Pretty much every scene with Roy Mustang in it was entirely worthless. Since he never deals with Pride, there's no reason to show him getting information about Selim. We'll never see Madam Christmas again, so acknowleding that she's Roy's adoptive mother is also a waste. The scene with him meeting with his subordinates is another thing that should have happened off-screen, but is played here for cheap sentimentality, your basic "don't die" speech from a shonen hero. Okay, the scene in itself doesn't bother me, but in concert with the previous scene it did. And did we really even have to see Roy and the gang kidnap the president's wife, too? Not only has this not sprung any kind of fruit in the manga thus far (105 chapters in), but cutting it down to them getting into the car would have made the same point just as easily as showing exactly how they did it. And since two of these scenes cut into the fight with Pride, it was extra annoying.
Speaking of the fight with the homunculi, it was good to see Edward Elric, the Fullmetal Alchemist, the main character of the story, actually do something that made some sort of difference (hope you like it, since you won't see him do anything of significance for quite a while). I liked his idea of imitating Greed by hardening his automail via the carbon elements in it. Still, though, why didn't Pride just continue at him? Eventually Edward would have lost his stamina and Pride would easily have been able to overcome him. I also wonder exactly what it is that swallowing Gluttony does for Pride, since in pitch dark he can't even use his abilities, so what good does it do to be able to find them with smell? If anything, he should have taken Alphonse while he had the chance and reorganized a new strategy, maybe bring Kimbley in or something. And poor Gluttony! I really did feel bad for him in the end.
The Xingese do kick ass, but boy are their abilities ever convenient to the point of annoyance. I still feel like they belong in a different series altogether most of the time. I can't wait for Greed to claim Ling's body again and for Ranfan and Fu to make their exit again. I know I'm probably in the minority, but these guys irritate the shit out of me, I don't care how much ass they kick. In fact, that's the whole problem with them, as soon as they arrive, they kick all the ass and nobody else really has the chance to.
Well, Hohenheim will have a cool scene in the next episode. I'm really looking forward to that.

Overall Score: 3.5 out of 5
![]() |
You can follow us on Twitter! While we're not sure why you'd want to peer into our life ramblings and nonsensical updates, you're more than welcome to. We do post about OR updates, gunpla, and misc anime news from time to time... so that's sort of an upside. We go by PenguinTruth and Falldog (surprise). Note our awesomely customized Twitter pages. |






Finally Catching Up
For a few weeks I haven't really been watching the show, and I just now am catching up. The scene with Ranfan showing up and kicking some ass was awesome. The pacing of the show has been all over the place, but it is still enjoyable. I agree with the Mustang parts, a lot of it is just wasteful and isn't nearly as interesting as the fight that is going on with Ed and all of them. It is good to see all aspects of the story and characters, but I want to just see the fight all the way through, not in segments.
Can't wait for the Hohenheim part in the next one, seems like he is still shrouded in mystery as to how powerful he really is.
Post new comment